News
Metrics matter: Measuring the true price of food for a healthy and sustainable future
13 Jun 2022Food value chains must begin to price in the ‘externalities’ of production, including impacts on human and planetary health, if the world is to realistically create a healthy and sustainable food supply to feed a growing population, according to one of the top experts at Rabobank.
Speaking at the F&A Next conference in Wageningen, the Netherlands, Berry Marttin, member of the managing board at Rabobank reiterated previous warnings of the challenges the world faces in feeding an estimated 10 billion people by 2050 – noting that the sheer scale of the challenge to produce enough food is being compounded by other factors, including pricing and supply chain issues in the current food supply and the climate crisis.
![Metrics matter: Measuring the true price of food for a healthy and sustainable future](/47/pdcnewsitem/11/78/02/True-price-of-food-for-healthy-and-sustainable-future.png)
“We have to be four or five times more efficient at producing each calorie,” said Marttin.
The Rabobank expert noted that the world needs to effectively increase the number of calories being produced globally by 60% in order to feed the expected 10 billion people in the world – adding that the majority of this population growth is expected to be seen in Asia and Africa.
At the same time, however, he warned of the critical importance of staying within a 2°C global warming limit, which would effectively mean not exceeding more than four gigatons of carbon emissions per year.
“Actually, the challenge that we have, is that we need to produce per calorie four to five times more efficiently,” he said. “This is the challenge that we're looking at as society.”
The price isn’t right: Measuring the true cost of food
Marttin noted that in order to talk about value of something, the industry will first need to have the right metrics – warning that in the case of food production, there are currently too many measures and not enough agreement of which ones should be used.
He noted, for example, that simply looking at sustainability based on carbon footprint metrics will skew food choices one way and may result in foods and diets that have lower nutritional value, but that looking solely at nutritional value may also cause a skew towards foods with higher carbon footprints.
Adding water use into the mix adds even more confusion to the metrics, he warned, commenting that it becomes ‘impossible’ to tell which foods are the best to grow, or what the true cost of diets may be to the environment or wider health systems.
“True value is about asking ‘do we really pay for all the externalities that are in the product that we are making?’,” Marttin said, noting that the number one driver of purchase decisions for consumers is price – followed by convenience and taste.
“Look at the difference between beef that can be produced lean with low environmental impact and beef that has actually high impact,” he said. “At the supermarket those two have exactly the same price. Is that right?”
The Rabobank board member noted that since consumers can buy both high and low impact beef very conveniently from most supermarkets, the only real differentiator to purchase could be price.
“What is the incentive [for the farmer] to move from having high impact beef production to go to the low impact?” he said. “There's absolutely zero incentive because there's no payment for it.”
The cost of food externalities to people & planet is ‘huge’
The expert cited data presented at the most recent United Nations Food Systems Summit in New York, which showed that we only pay for approximately one third of the true value of food.
“The true value of food actually has two externalities,” he said – citing both the environmental cost of food production and the impact on human health of food consumption.
“Actually, the cost to society is huge,” he said. “The health impact of not having proper nutritious food is enormous. It’s 12 trillion dollars, which is more than the value of food itself”
Eco-labels and nutrition labels could shift consumer mindsets
Because of this, Marttin noted that changing consumer mindsets and pricing in ‘externalities’ would be key to shifting the conversation on food and pricing.
“Two things are starting to happen. We are already starting to see Nutri score,” he said. “You feel guilty if you buy a D product, right?”
“But the other thing we are starting to see is the eco label,” he said, noting that eco labels are already used in certain Belgian supermarkets.
“The moment that you start crossing nutrition and eco label, it starts to become interesting,” he added, noting that early reports in Belgium show that products with high (A or B) scores on both nutrition and eco labels had a 10%-15% uplift in sales after the labelling system was introduced.
Metrics matter: We need scientific guidance on managing data
Marttin warned that data will become ‘essential’ in the food value chain and noted the need for scientific guidance on how to manage the data process in food value chains.
“We need to get the right metrics going. Because if we want to get true value, we need to know that what are we measuring and how we're measuring.”
“There is a lot of data that will need to be flowing in the value chain,” he said. “How do you measure that? What is it? And how are we going to share data?”
Related news
![Israel approves Aleph Farms’ cell-cultured beef in world first](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/36/18/th123618.png)
Israel approves Aleph Farms’ cell-cultured beef in world first
1 Feb 2024
Israel has granted the first regulatory approval for the commercial sale of cultivated beef, joining the US and Singapore in officially recognising cultivated meat’s role towards protein diversification.
Read more![Fazer and Solar Foods launch snack bar made with air protein](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/35/94/th123594.png)
Fazer and Solar Foods launch snack bar made with air protein
30 Jan 2024
Finnish food manufacturer Fazer has teamed up with foodtech startup Solar Foods to launch a limited-edition snack bar in Singapore made using a novel, carbon-fed microbial protein.
Read more![Big brands invest in precision fermentation-derived palm oil](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/35/60/th123560.png)
Big brands invest in precision fermentation-derived palm oil
25 Jan 2024
Although still not approved for food applications, big brands such as Unilever and Doehler are investing in precision fermentation-derived palm oil in a bid to reduce the environmental impact associated with this conventional palm oil.
Read more![Supergrain fonio expands its reach in US market](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/34/41/th123441.png)
Supergrain fonio expands its reach in US market
11 Jan 2024
More US consumers will find nutritious, climate-smart grain fonio in supermarkets thanks to a new distribution structure for the import’s most prominent commercial brand, Yolélé.
Read more![Sustainability meets innovation at Fi Europe 2023's Sustainability Ingredients Zone](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/34/38/th123438.png)
Sustainability meets innovation at Fi Europe 2023's Sustainability Ingredients Zone
9 Jan 2024
Fi Europe’s Sustainable Ingredients Zone showcases ingredients forging a path toward a greener future. Three innovators are redefining what sustainability within the food and beverage industry means, with upcycled products, regenerative agriculture, an...
Read more![Supermarkets innovate with private label plant-based ranges](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/34/37/th123437.png)
Supermarkets innovate with private label plant-based ranges
9 Jan 2024
Plant-based product ranges are an important part of retailers’ private label innovation efforts – and represent an important way for supermarkets to reduce their environmental impact.
Read more![The UK prepares to open food security science centre](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/33/66/th123366.png)
The UK prepares to open food security science centre
2 Jan 2024
Amid global food insecurity, the UK government says it is committed to producing crops resilient to climate change and addressing hunger and malnutrition with a food security science centre.
Read more![Novel food safety platform could eliminate animal testing](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/33/64/th123364.png)
Novel food safety platform could eliminate animal testing
21 Dec 2023
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has introduced a new platform that has the potential to eliminate animal testing in the food industry.
Read more![Water-conscious consumers, upcycled food, and tech-driven sustainability: Highlights from Fi Europe, part 2](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/33/26/th123326.png)
Water-conscious consumers, upcycled food, and tech-driven sustainability: Highlights from Fi Europe, part 2
14 Dec 2023
With climate change becoming a tangible reality, consumers’ environmental concerns are changing. At Fi Europe, market analysts revealed how people are now interested in everyday issues like water shortages and tech-driven solutions such as GM drought-r...
Read more![The food industry’s single-use packaging problem](/47/pdcnewsitem/12/32/90/th123290.png)
The food industry’s single-use packaging problem
12 Dec 2023
The food industry’s reliance on single-use packaging is a sustainability “sticking point” with viable alternatives not widely available – but new EU rules mean food businesses will remain responsible for the collection and disposal of the packaging the...
Read more