News

Brazilian manufacturers must comply with warning label regulation, says court

7 Mar 2024

The Federal Court of São Paulo has ruled that Brazilian manufacturers must comply with front-of-pack labelling regulation that requires unhealthy products to feature warning labels, scrapping a last-minute one-year extension.

The February court injunction went in favour of the Brazilian Institute of Consumer Protection (IDEC), which had brought legal proceedings against the regulatory agency, ANVISA, for extending the October 2023 deadline by one year.

Brazilian manufacturers must comply with warning label regulation, says court
© iStock/FG Trade

Front-of-pack warning label extension scrapped

In 2020, Brazilian policymakers approved the regulation RDC nº 429/2020, which introduced front-of-pack warning labels on products that exceed certain nutrient thresholds. The mandatory nutrition warning label features a magnifying glass that alerts consumers to products high in sodium, added sugar, and saturated fat.

Manufacturers had a grace period of three years to ensure their product packaging complied with the regulation, which also introduced a nutrition fact table presenting nutrient information per 100 ml or 100 g of product. Only small producers and non-alcoholic drinks in returnable packaging were granted more time to comply, meaning a general deadline for compliance of October 2023.

However, in October last year, ANVISA issued a new regulation, RDC nº 819/2023, pushing back the deadline to October 2024. In response, IDEC filed a public civil action against ANVISA seeking to restore the original deadline.

Extension based on interference from the food industry, says IDEC

Last month, a São Paolo court decided in favour of IDEC, issuing an injunction that suspended the effects of RDC nº 819/2023. In its public civil action, IDEC argued that ANVISA’s decision was based on biased information from the food industry and was devoid of any independent scientific evidence.

According to ANVISA, the October 2024 extension was necessary so that manufacturers could exhaust their existing labels and packaging stock. However, IDEC pointed out that the regulation already allowed manufacturers to use existing stock by simply adding an updated sticker to the packaging, thus minimising food waste while ensuring consumers had access to easy-to-understand nutritional information.

IDEC criticised the consumer packaged goods (CPG) industry for “fail(ing) to organise itself within the 1,000 days they had to adapt to the new nutritional labelling rules to the detriment of the public interest”.

According to the injunction, cited on IDEC’s website, the judge questioned ANVISA’s action, asking: “How can we explain that 57 isolated requests led to the alteration – in a few days – of a public policy destined to cover thousands, perhaps millions, of food manufacturers under RDC nº 429/2020?”

IDEC: Injunction is ‘a very positive response’

Leonardo Pillon, senior lawyer at IDEC's healthy and sustainable food programme, said the judge’s preliminary decision was “a very positive response”. He criticised ANVISA for bowing to the interests of industry, adding that it was extremely damaging to the agency’s reputation.

“There is a double loss of the agency's credibility: internally, by having disregarded the positions of its own technical [remit], and externally by having suppressed social participation,” he said in a statement translated from Portuguese.

According to the IDEC lawyer, the court’s decision consolidated the right of Brazilian consumers to make more informed choices about the potential harmful effects on health of ultra-processed and processed products. Brazil, the largest country in South America, has growing rates of obesity, overweight, and other non-communicable diseases linked to an unhealthy diet.

Asked if it had a response to the court injunction, a spokesperson for ANVISA told Ingredients Network it would present its position in a legal proceeding. 

Related news

Value is a top priority for today’s F&B consumers

Value is a top priority for today’s F&B consumers

3 Apr 2025

Research from global consultancy Hartman Group suggests there are six core values that brands must tap into to connect with consumers’ needs.

Read more 
Lidl GB debuts on TikTok Shop with high-protein foods promotion

Lidl GB debuts on TikTok Shop with high-protein foods promotion

2 Apr 2025

Lidl GB has become the first UK grocery retailer to sell on TikTok Shop, with its limited edition run of high-protein bundles selling out in under 20 minutes.

Read more 
Clean-label cereals prompt fortification debate

Clean-label cereals prompt fortification debate

28 Mar 2025

Marks & Spencer has caused a stir with the launch of a range of breakfast cereals in the UK containing minimal ingredients.

Read more 
Changing global food retail environments linked to rise in obesity

Changing global food retail environments linked to rise in obesity

27 Mar 2025

Changes in retail food environments – particularly the growing prominence of large chains – are positively correlated with rising obesity prevalence, a study suggests.

Read more 
Future F&B flavours favour exploration and explosive taste profiles

Future F&B flavours favour exploration and explosive taste profiles

25 Mar 2025

Exploration and experimentation will define the future of flavour, according to Mintel, as consumers seek out taste profiles and textures that offer an adventurous eating experience.

Read more 
Global consumers enjoy food less and perceive it as less healthy

Global consumers enjoy food less and perceive it as less healthy

20 Mar 2025

Enjoyment of food and its perceived healthiness is dwindling among most global populations, according to findings from Gallup and Ando Foundation/Nissin Food Products.

Read more 
Plans to abandon mandatory Nutri-Score labelling ‘would be a step back’

Plans to abandon mandatory Nutri-Score labelling ‘would be a step back’

17 Mar 2025

Critics have slammed reports that mandatory Nutri-Score labelling is to be abandoned as “a step back” that puts citizens’ health at risk.

Read more 
Food companies urged to bring ‘joy’ and urgency to healthy food mission

Food companies urged to bring ‘joy’ and urgency to healthy food mission

14 Mar 2025

For too long, businesses have treated health and sustainability as separate agendas – but there is growing evidence to show diets that benefit human health can also enhance that of the planet, say experts.

Read more 
HFSS product placement regulation hits unhealthy food displays

HFSS product placement regulation hits unhealthy food displays

6 Mar 2025

The proportion of space used to display HFSS foods in UK supermarkets fell following the introduction of regulations restricting the location of product promotions, research shows.

Read more 
Smaller snack sizes represent big growth opportunity for PepsiCo

Smaller snack sizes represent big growth opportunity for PepsiCo

5 Mar 2025

Brands are responding to consumer demand for healthier products by developing classic snacks in smaller portion sizes, meaning fewer calories, lower sodium, and lower fat.

Read more